#378 ‒ Women's health and performance: how training, nutrition, and hormones interact across life stages | Abbie Smith-Ryan, Ph.D.
Timestamps are as accurate as they can be but may be slightly off. We encourage you to listen to the full context.
Podcast Summary
Exercise physiologist Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan joins Peter Attia to explore the nuanced landscape of women's health and training across the entire lifespan. This comprehensive discussion delves deep into how exercise and nutrition needs evolve from childhood through menopause, covering everything from building bone density in young girls to managing metabolic flexibility during perimenopause. (03:00)
Main Theme: Understanding how women can optimize exercise and nutrition strategies throughout their life cycles, with particular emphasis on the critical perimenopause transition period.
Speakers
Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan
Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan is the Associate Chair for Research in the Department of Exercise and Sports Science at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where she directs the Applied Physiology Lab and co-directs the Human Performance Center. A former collegiate distance runner, she has authored more than 180 peer-reviewed papers and led NIH and industry-funded trials focused on body composition, metabolism, and cardiovascular health, with special attention to women's health through perimenopause and postmenopause.
Peter Attia, MD
Dr. Peter Attia is a physician focused on the applied science of longevity, the host of The Drive podcast, and the author of the #1 New York Times bestseller "Outlive." He is the founder of Early Medical, a medical practice that applies the principles of Medicine 3.0 to patients with the goal of lengthening their lifespan and simultaneously improving their healthspan.
Key Takeaways
Exercise is the Best Medicine Across All Life Stages
Starting physical activity early creates a foundation that benefits women throughout their entire lives. (05:42) Smith-Ryan emphasizes that exercise begun in childhood, initially as play and then transitioning to structured activity, builds crucial bone density, muscle development, and cardiovascular fitness that becomes harder to achieve later in life. The earlier women start and the better base they establish, the easier it becomes to maintain fitness over time. For young girls specifically, diverse sport participation rather than early specialization provides the best foundation for lifelong health.
Understanding and Working with Your Menstrual Cycle
Women can train at any point in their cycle, but understanding hormonal fluctuations helps optimize performance and recovery. (16:16) During the follicular phase (days 1-14), women typically feel better and have greater carbohydrate oxidation. The luteal phase (post-ovulation) brings increased metabolic rate, potential fluid retention, and greater inflammation. Rather than completely restructuring training around cycles, Smith-Ryan advocates for giving yourself grace during difficult phases and potentially adjusting recovery strategies, such as increasing omega-3 intake (2-3 grams) and focusing on sleep quality during the luteal phase.
Perimenopause Represents a Critical Window for Intervention
The perimenopause transition, typically occurring in the 40s and 50s, shows the most dramatic changes in muscle quality, metabolism, and bone health - making this period crucial for exercise and nutrition interventions. (37:18) Smith-Ryan's research reveals that muscle quality changes most significantly during perimenopause, with less dramatic shifts once women reach postmenopause. This makes the perimenopausal years a critical time to implement resistance training and proper nutrition to preserve muscle mass and metabolic function for the rest of life.
Intensity Trumps Volume When Time is Limited
For busy women with limited time, high-intensity exercise provides greater benefits than longer, moderate-intensity sessions. (45:54) Smith-Ryan's research demonstrates that when training time is constrained to just a few hours per week, prioritizing intensity over volume becomes essential. Her recommended protocol includes 10 sets of one minute on, one minute off at 90-110% of max heart rate, which can be completed in just 20 minutes total. This approach is particularly valuable for perimenopausal women who need to maximize training stimulus while managing busy schedules with work and family responsibilities.
Body Composition Goals Should Replace Weight Loss Obsession
Rather than focusing solely on the scale, women should prioritize improving body composition through resistance training and adequate protein intake. (53:51) Smith-Ryan explains that many women can improve their health and appearance without losing weight by replacing fat with muscle. She advocates for using DEXA scans or other body composition measurements to set realistic goals based on reducing body fat percentage to the 25th percentile or lower, rather than arbitrary weight targets. This approach is particularly important when using GLP-1 medications, where maintaining muscle mass requires deliberate resistance training and 1.6-2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight daily.
Statistics & Facts
- Only about 19% of women participate in resistance training, and typically just one day per week. (82:25) This statistic, cited from research by Bill Kramer, highlights the significant gap in strength training participation among women of all ages.
- Women typically experience about a 200-300 calorie per day increase in metabolic rate during the luteal phase of their menstrual cycle. (29:01) This increased energy expenditure occurs when women often feel their worst, creating a perfect storm for under-consumption of calories.
- Smith-Ryan personally experienced nine stress fractures during her collegiate running career when her body fat dropped below 15%. (67:25) This demonstrates how even moderately low body fat levels can significantly impact bone health and injury risk in female athletes.
