China and the Reordering of World Trade | Former Under Secretary of the Treasury for International Affairs Jay Shambaugh
Timestamps are as accurate as they can be but may be slightly off. We encourage you to listen to the full context.
Podcast Summary
In this episode of Monetary Matters, economist Jay Shambaugh—former Under Secretary of the Treasury for International Affairs—discusses U.S.-China economic relations, trade policy, and the current administration's approach to tariffs and immigration. (00:50) Shambaugh explains how China's fundamental economic imbalances, driven by excessive savings and state-directed overcapacity, create global distortions that affect manufacturing worldwide. He critiques the current administration's chaotic tariff implementation, arguing it damages U.S. credibility while failing to address China's structural issues effectively. (07:42) The conversation covers the economic impacts of immigration flows, Federal Reserve challenges with rising unemployment amid persistent inflation, and the broader implications of America's shifting role in global economic leadership.
- Core themes include China's economic imbalances creating global trade distortions, the ineffectiveness of unilateral trade policy approaches, and the economic consequences of policy uncertainty on business investment and growth.
Speakers
Jay Shambaugh
Jay Shambaugh is an economist at George Washington University and former Under Secretary of the U.S. Treasury for International Affairs under the Biden administration. He previously served at the Council of Economic Advisors at the White House and worked at Dartmouth College. Shambaugh has extensive expertise in international economics, trade policy, and macroeconomic analysis, with particular focus on U.S.-China economic relations and global financial stability.
Key Takeaways
China's Structural Imbalances Drive Global Trade Tensions
China's economy operates with fundamental imbalances—extremely high savings rates that exceed even their massive investment levels, creating persistent current account surpluses. (00:50) This isn't just a trade issue; it's a macroeconomic reality where China produces more than it consumes, forcing that excess production into global markets. As China has grown to become the world's second-largest economy and dominant manufacturer, these imbalances now significantly impact everyone else. The challenge intensifies when China's state-driven system directs resources toward specific industries at specific times, creating "overcapacity" that distorts global production and makes it impossible for market-based firms to compete profitably.
Effective China Policy Requires Multilateral Coordination
The Biden administration's approach focused on building multilateral pressure through G7 statements, coordinated tariffs with allies, and consistent messaging that the world wouldn't accept China's economic distortions. (06:38) Shambaugh emphasizes this strategy was showing success—Canada mirrored U.S. tariffs, Europe imposed EV tariffs, and countries worldwide began implementing anti-dumping measures. However, the current administration's unilateral approach has fractured this coalition, making China feel they can weather a trade war with just the U.S. while maintaining relationships with other nations.
Policy Uncertainty Devastates Business Investment
Shambaugh illustrates how the current administration's "strategic ambiguity" on tariffs creates massive uncertainty that prevents businesses from making crucial investment decisions. (38:07) His Christmas tree vendor example—where the owner couldn't order mugs because tariff uncertainty made cost planning impossible—demonstrates how small businesses suffer. Larger firms face similar paralysis: when you don't know if tariffs will be 20% or 50%, the option value of waiting increases dramatically, leading to reduced investment and hiring across the economy.
Immigration Flows Significantly Impact Labor Markets and Economic Data
The reversal from high immigration under Biden to negative flows under Trump represents a major economic shock that's making Federal Reserve policy decisions more difficult. (52:03) Shambaugh explains that high immigration helped cool inflation by increasing labor supply, while current deportation efforts are reducing labor supply even as unemployment rises. This creates unusual labor market dynamics where typical job growth expectations no longer apply, and even legal immigrants may avoid responding honestly to government surveys out of fear.
Trade Wars Damage Long-term Economic Growth
While tariffs don't cause immediate recessions, they create lasting damage by reducing efficiency and slowing growth over time. (25:37) Shambaugh cites research showing that when trade costs increase (like during Suez Canal closures), countries most affected see measurably slower growth. The current tariff structure forces firms to shift supply chains away from optimal sources, reduces productivity growth in leading export firms (which typically pay higher wages), and creates a regressive tax system that disproportionately burdens lower-income households.
Statistics & Facts
- China's current account surplus is approaching 3.5% of their GDP, which represents roughly the same impact on global GDP as their 10% surplus did in 2008, due to China's dramatically larger economic scale. (1:13:05)
- The unemployment rate has risen from around 3.5% to over 4% while immigration flows have turned negative, representing an unusual economic situation where labor supply is contracting but unemployment is still increasing. (56:02)
- Research suggests that an effective tariff rate of 10% could reduce economic growth by one to two-tenths of a percentage point over time, representing significant cumulative losses. (37:33)
